Book Review: Monsters Born and Made by Tanvi Berwah

The Short Version

Blurb

Koral is a lowly Hunter. She sheds her blood capturing and breeding sea monsters for the nobles’ Glory Race.

When a medical emergency threatens Koral’s family, she enters the Glory Race to win the prize money. Koral faces the nobles’ wrath in a competition never intended for lowly Hunters.

The nobles have taken everything else. The Glory Race belongs to Koral.

Recommendation

Strengths

Koral is an angry, proud young woman.

She overcomes lots of obstacles as she struggles to win the Glory Race against all odds.

I especially loved the familial tension. Everyone in Monsters Born and Made stands in Koral’s way.

She never falters in her determination to win a better life for her loved ones.

Weaknesses

Monsters Born and Made falls short in the climax.

One of the villains feels a little unauthentic. I didn’t really believe that this particular villain had the pre-existing personality to do what they did in the climax.

Koral’s character arc needed more organic growth. I’m not convinced that the ending matched up with the pre-existing story’s trajectory.

Highlights:

  • Strong heroine: Koral’s pride is only matched by her determination to save her family.

  • South Asian-inspired world: islands, muggy heat, sea monsters, and steep class divides.

  • No Romance (for the most part): Monsters Born and Made has a very small romantic subplot. The characters are well-rounded. I like that their story revolves around understanding each other’s choices. Not an HEA.

  • Tragic elements

  • 3/5 Stars


The Comprehensive Version

Characters

Strengths

Overall, I liked the characters. Every character is messed up in some way. Koral has her pride and anger. Crane has her daddy issues. Emrik is too protective for his own good.

I love how Emrik’s protective big-brother instincts make trouble for Koral throughout the story. It’s a great example of a virtue that goes too far.

Koral has an interesting relationship with rebellion. She does not believe in political or fundamental rebellion, but she is a rebellious person.

Koral is determined to beat the Landers at their own game, rules and all. She simultaneously hates the rebel movement.

The odd combination of rule-following and rebellion feels completely organic to Koral’s character.

Weaknesses

Dorian is by far the most irritating person in Monsters Born and Made. He has all the arrogant possessiveness of a classic bad-boy antagonist/love interest without the charisma to match.

Koral’s pride and anger are the things that made me like her. She has justifiable anger. I liked that her pride kept her strong in the face of antagonism.

The fact that her pride and anger wind up being her biggest stumbling blocks feels like a mistake.

Koral’s pride and anger were not excessive enough to be significant character flaws.


Conflict

Strengths

The story opens with Koral and Emrik wrangling an ocean velociraptor creature. That sets the tone for a conflict-filled adventure.

Aside from Koral’s push-pull relationship with Dorian, Koral’s relationship with her family is the most interesting source of conflict.

Not only does Koral as a YA heroine have her entire family around, but most of them have big problems.

Even sweet, innocent Liria battles a life-threatening lung condition.

These minor stressors culminate in bigger problems for Koral because everyone thinks that she is crazy for racing in the Glory Race.

Weaknesses

I was disappointed with the ending. One of the antagonists took a turn that did not mesh with the rest of their story.

The ending might have had setup with the beginning of the story, but I still found it unsatisfying.


Romance

There are some hints of romance between Koral and Dorian. Overall, this is a non-romantic story that focuses on healing past hurts.

There is a very bare-bones love triangle. The love triangle does no favors for the story. Judas’s purpose is to provide contrast for Dorian because they are very different people.

The problem is that Judas winds up highlighting Dorian’s negative traits.

Sometimes, I’ll write a foil character and then realize after re-reading my draft that the foil character ends up being way, way more likable than the person I created them to foil. Bummer, right?

I think that’s what is happening here.


Worldbuilding/Atmosphere

This is a South Asian-inspired world. It feels like Jurassic Park opened an exhibit in Atlantis.

The lore about the world that existed before the ten islands is interesting.

I wish there would have been a greater focus on the interesting pieces of lore. That would have made the world much more immersive.


Closing Thoughts

Strengths

I enjoyed Koral’s seriousness. Her driving desire to save her family at all costs is a compelling story goal.

The supporting characters have solid motivations. Koral’s relationships are tense and dynamic.

There is wonderful contrast between Koral’s relationship with Liria and her relationship with Emrik, the cynical, overprotective big brother.

Weaknesses

Monsters Born and Made would have been 4/5 stars if not for the finale. The finale did some things that didn’t have a lot of setup/payoff value. I also wasn’t convinced that Koral’s character arc was organic.

Her major flaws of pride and anger served her for most of the story. I would have loved to see more emotional detriments for Koral’s actions.

Bad things happen to Koral and her family. However, it seems like these consequences happen because the perpetrators are bad people, not because Koral’s character flaws are ruining her life.

Characters should earn the consequences that happen because of the mistakes they make.

Recommendation

Monsters Born and Made is a solid choice if you enjoy books with tragic elements and difficult relationships. Burning anger and undiminished pride make the protagonist a powerful lead.

3/5 Stars


The Professional Beta Reader Review: Episode 1 (Spoilers)

I did not beta read for Monsters Born and Made. Here is some of the feedback I would have given if I had.

Notes on the Story’s Tragic Nature

Monsters Born and Made is a classic Tragedy. The problem is that Monsters Born and Made had all the tropes of a happy ending, so the ending unpleasantly surprised me.

I mean, come on. We’ve got:

  • Enemies to friends, back to enemies, enemies-to-friends-to-lovers (that’s enough relationship drama to warrant a happy ending!)

  • Love triangle

  • Looming rebellion

  • Corrupt government

  • Scrappy heroine

  • Death games

These tropes led me to believe that we’d get an HEA.

What is a Classic Tragedy?

A classic Tragedy happens when the protagonist fails to accomplish their story goal.

The story goal can be anything. Adopting a puppy from the local shelter can be a story goal. If the character adopts the puppy successfully—it’s a Comedy! Time to celebrate.

If the character fails to adopt the puppy—it’s a Tragedy! Time to mourn as we reflect on how our shortcomings ultimately led us to this woefully puppy-less existence.

Monsters Born and Made is a Tragedy

Why is this book a Tragedy?

Koral’s story goal is to save her family by winning the Glory Race.

Koral wins the race. She does not save her family.

There are some allusions that Koral’s secret goal is to be free. If that were the case, Koral had a happy ending because she and Stormgold escape Sollonia.

Koral never wanted that kind of freedom.

She wanted the freedom that came with wealth, not the kind of freedom that meant swapping one kind of poverty for another.

Tragedies are great. They are one of the most respected of classic genres, and I love that Berwah went for it in Monsters Born and Made. The tragic elements had a couple of spots that could be strengthened for greater impact.

Does Monsters Born and Made work as a Tragedy?

The short answer is: no.

The long answer is: it could work with a couple of tweaks. Monsters Born and Made has too many strong points to be sunk by its finale.

I’d love to see a stronger correlation between Koral’s flaws and failures. That one change would dramatically improve the ending’s effectiveness.

Koral is the Titanic. Koral’s flaws are icebergs. It makes sense when her flaws are big enough that they ultimately sink her.

I’d also love to see Landmaster Minos play a bigger role as the main villain. Landmaster Minos is treated like the scariest villain on Sollonia but readers rarely see her do anything to directly oppose Koral.

Switching it up to have Landmaster Minos be a more villainous puppeteer would raise the tension because Minos is scarier, deadlier, and far more powerful than any of the other antagonists.

Some Notes on the Villains

Arlene goes psycho in the final race and tries to murder Koral in front of an audience. Why?

Arlene hated Koral from the beginning. Arlene was never above cheating.

But hardcore murder? I never got the feeling that Arlene was the kind of person to throw her goals aside in favor of revenge.

Fleshing out Arlene’s jump from super mean girl to super psycho would have improved the finale.

Here are my suggestions on ways to improve Arlene’s villain arc:

  1. Build on the hatred Arlene already has for Hunters like Koral. Show it earlier, play on it harder, and give Arlene a bigger role as a villain. Make Arlene the mastermind behind some of the attacks on Koral and her family.

  2. Arlene might be incredibly jealous of the attention Koral receives from Dorian. Show her getting more obsessed until she snaps in the arena and tries to murder Koral.

Arlene is a great choice for a villain. I disliked her from the beginning. I enjoyed watching her fail.

That’s a Wrap

There you go! That was some of the feedback I would have given if I had been a beta reader for Monsters Born and Made.

Until next time, happy reading!

Join our crew of readers for fantasy book reviews and recommendations!

Next
Next

Fantasy Books with Strong Female Protagonists (no, really)